Kettle Craft vs Crumps Naturals vs Fare Game Dog Treats Canada 2026: Which Canadian-Made Treat Brand Is Best?

Canada produces some of the world's most trusted dog treat brands — and three of the most talked-about names in 2026 are Kettle Craft, Crumps' Naturals, and Fare Game. All three are proudly Canadian-made, all three prioritize natural ingredients, and all three are available right here at Ashario Pets in North York. But they serve very different dogs and very different treat occasions. If you're trying to decide which brand belongs in your treat rotation, this head-to-head comparison breaks it all down — ingredients, protein content, treat formats, and which dogs each brand suits best.

Whether you're shopping for dog treats in North York or ordering to your GTA doorstep via Uber Eats or DoorDash, understanding what separates these three Canadian brands will help you make a smarter choice for your dog's health and taste preferences. Let's get into it.

Key Takeaway: Kettle Craft excels for everyday crunchy rewards, Crumps' Naturals leads for training treats and dental formats, and Fare Game stands out for single-ingredient wild protein treats. The best pick depends on your dog's age, size, dietary needs, and how you use treats daily.

Why Canadian-Made Dog Treats Matter in 2026

As of 2026, Canadian pet owners are increasingly prioritizing treats manufactured domestically, where ingredient sourcing standards and facility oversight fall under Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) regulations. Canadian-made treats are also more likely to use locally sourced proteins — a meaningful quality signal for ingredient transparency.

According to the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA), treats should account for no more than 10% of a dog's total daily caloric intake. That means even "healthy" treats need to be chosen with guaranteed analysis in mind — fat content, protein content, and caloric density all matter, not just the ingredient list on the front of the bag.

All three brands — Kettle Craft, Crumps' Naturals, and Fare Game — are carried at Ashario Pets, located at 1111A Finch Ave W, Unit 2, North York, ON M3J 2P7, open 7 AM to 11 PM daily, 365 days a year. Our team sees customers come in regularly from the Jane-Finch corridor, Wilson Heights, and the Yonge-Finch neighbourhood asking us specifically about Canadian treat options, and these three brands are consistently at the top of those conversations.

Kettle Craft Dog Treats: Artisan Crunch with Whole Ingredients

Kettle Craft produces small-batch, oven-baked dog treats using whole-food ingredients with no artificial preservatives, colours, or flavours. Their biscuit-style formats are designed for dogs who enjoy a satisfying crunch, and their formulas typically feature protein sources like chicken, salmon, or beef as primary ingredients.

Kettle Craft treats generally deliver around 18–22% protein and 8–12% fat depending on the recipe, with moderate fiber content that supports digestive regularity. The oven-baked format keeps moisture low — typically under 12% — which extends shelf life without artificial preservatives. Their ingredient panels are short and readable, which our team at Ashario Pets finds resonates strongly with owners of dogs with food sensitivities.

Kettle Craft is an especially strong fit for:

• Medium to large dogs who enjoy a hearty biscuit treat
• Dogs on limited ingredient diets who need clearly sourced proteins
• Owners who want a grain-inclusive or grain-free crunchy option
• Everyday reward moments — post-walk, post-training, or just because

Our nutrition experts at the North York store often recommend Kettle Craft for senior dogs who still have good dental health but whose owners want to move away from mass-market biscuits full of fillers and artificial additives. The palatability is high — dogs love the crunch and the whole-food aroma.

Crumps' Naturals Dog Treats: Freeze-Dried and Dental Formats for Versatile Use

Crumps' Naturals is one of Canada's most versatile treat brands, offering everything from freeze-dried liver bites and sweet potato chews to plaque-busting dental sticks. Founded in Ontario, Crumps' Naturals has built its reputation on functional treat formats that serve a real nutritional or dental purpose — not just a snack.

Their freeze-dried liver treats are a standout: single-ingredient, high-protein (often 55–65% protein on a dry matter basis), and low in fat content — typically under 8% fat. This makes them ideal as training treats, where caloric density needs to stay controlled across dozens of repetitions per session. A single Crumps' freeze-dried liver treat weighs approximately 1–2 grams, making them easy to portion even for small breeds.

The American Kennel Club (AKC) notes that high-value, low-calorie treats with strong protein aromas are among the most effective tools for positive reinforcement training — exactly what Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried liver delivers.

Crumps' Naturals is a strong fit for:

• Dogs in active training programs — puppy classes, obedience, sport work
• Small breeds where low-calorie treats prevent weight gain during training
• Dogs who need dental support — their Plaque Busters line targets tartar build-up
• Owners wanting a Canadian-made freeze-dried treat alternative to imported options
• Multi-dog households where a high-palatability, easy-to-split treat is practical

Pet owners tell us that Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried bites are often the only treat that holds a dog's focus in distraction-heavy environments. That says a lot about palatability and motivational value.

Fare Game Dog Treats: Wild Canadian Proteins for Ancestral Nutrition

Fare Game is a smaller, specialty Canadian brand that focuses exclusively on wild-caught and sustainably harvested proteins — think wild boar, venison, elk, rabbit, and bison. Their treats are typically single-ingredient or close to it, and they align closely with the ancestral, species-appropriate treat philosophy that's popular among raw feeding households.

Fare Game treats tend to be air-dried or dehydrated to preserve nutritional integrity without high-heat processing. Protein content can reach 60–70% on a dry matter basis for their meat-based formats, with fat content varying by protein source — wild boar and venison tend to be leaner than beef-based options. These are not training-volume treats; they're high-value, low-frequency rewards.

Research published by the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) supports the nutritional value of novel protein sources for dogs with food sensitivities, as proteins like venison and boar are less commonly used in commercial dog food, reducing the likelihood of prior sensitization.

Fare Game is a strong fit for:

• Dogs on raw or limited ingredient diets who need treat consistency
• Dogs with chicken or beef allergies who need novel protein treats
• Owners looking for grain-free, additive-free, single-source protein treats
• High-drive dogs who need a premium, high-value reward for exceptional behaviour
• Households already feeding raw food who want treat alignment with their diet philosophy

When a customer comes into our North York store asking specifically about treats for a dog with a known protein sensitivity, Fare Game is one of the first brands we reach for. The wild protein roster is genuinely unique in the Canadian market.

Kettle Craft vs Crumps' Naturals vs Fare Game: Side-by-Side Comparison

Here's how the three brands compare across the key dimensions that matter most to Canadian dog owners in 2026:

• Kettle Craft — Format: Oven-baked biscuits | Protein: 18–22% | Fat: 8–12% | Best for: Everyday rewards, medium-large dogs, whole-food biscuit lovers | Grain-free option: Yes | Available at Ashario: Yes
• Crumps' Naturals — Format: Freeze-dried bites, dental sticks, sweet potato chews | Protein: 55–65% (dry matter, freeze-dried) | Fat: Under 8% (freeze-dried) | Best for: Training, dental health, small breeds, high-repetition rewards | Grain-free option: Yes | Available at Ashario: Yes
• Fare Game — Format: Air-dried / dehydrated single-protein | Protein: 60–70% (dry matter) | Fat: Varies by protein source | Best for: Novel proteins, raw-aligned diets, food-sensitive dogs, high-value rewards | Grain-free option: Yes (all formulas) | Available at Ashario: Yes

All three brands meet the spirit of AAFCO ingredient quality guidelines, though as treats rather than complete diets, they are not required to carry a full AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement. Always review the guaranteed analysis panel and ingredient list on the specific SKU you purchase.

How to Choose: Matching the Brand to Your Dog's Needs

The right Canadian treat brand depends on your dog's lifestyle, health profile, and how you use treats day-to-day. Here's a practical decision guide based on what our team at Ashario Pets recommends across different customer scenarios:

• Training-focused owners: Start with Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried liver or beef. Small size, strong aroma, low calorie — ideal for 20–50 repetitions per session without caloric overload.
• Dogs with food sensitivities or novel protein needs: Fare Game is the clear choice. Wild boar, venison, and rabbit are rare in standard commercial diets, making them ideal limited ingredient treats.
• Dogs who love a crunchy biscuit: Kettle Craft's oven-baked formats deliver the satisfying crunch that many medium and large dogs crave, with whole-food ingredients you can actually read.
• Dogs with dental concerns: Crumps' Naturals Plaque Busters dental sticks pair mechanical chewing with natural ingredients to reduce tartar — always consult your vet for dogs with existing dental disease.
• Raw diet households: Fare Game and Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried options align best with a raw or ancestral feeding philosophy. Browse raw dog food at Ashario Pets to round out your dog's diet.

You can also mix and match. Many North York dog owners keep Crumps' Naturals for training sessions, Fare Game for high-value jackpot rewards, and Kettle Craft for casual daily treats. That's three tiers of treat currency — a strategy our team genuinely endorses for dogs in active training households.

Explore our full Canadian dog treats collection at Ashario Pets, and visit our made in Canada pet products page for a broader look at what's proudly domestic in our store.

Frequently Asked Questions: Canadian Dog Treats 2026

Are Kettle Craft, Crumps' Naturals, and Fare Game treats safe for puppies?

Most treats from all three brands are formulated for adult dogs and are not necessarily life-stage formulated for puppies. Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried liver bites — at approximately 1–2 grams each — can be appropriate for puppies over 12 weeks in very small amounts during training, but always verify with your veterinarian before introducing new treats to a puppy. Puppy digestive systems are still developing, and high-fat or high-protein treats in excessive quantities can cause gastrointestinal upset. Check individual product packaging for age guidance and consult your vet for puppies under six months.

What makes Fare Game treats different from other Canadian dog treat brands?

Fare Game specializes exclusively in wild and novel proteins — including venison, wild boar, elk, rabbit, and bison — that are rarely found in mainstream Canadian treat brands. These proteins are single-source, minimally processed via air-drying or dehydration, and are particularly valuable for dogs with known food sensitivities to common proteins like chicken or beef. Because these proteins are less commonly encountered in commercial diets, they carry a lower likelihood of triggering a prior dietary sensitivity response. This makes Fare Game uniquely positioned among Canadian treat brands for dogs on limited ingredient or elimination diets.

How many treats can I give my dog per day without affecting their diet?

The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) and most veterinary nutritionists recommend that treats not exceed 10% of a dog's total daily caloric intake. For a 25 lb (11 kg) dog consuming approximately 600–700 kcal per day, that's a treat budget of roughly 60–70 kcal. Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried liver bites are among the lowest-calorie options at roughly 2–4 kcal per piece, making them ideal for training. Kettle Craft biscuits and Fare Game air-dried treats tend to be more calorie-dense, so limit those to 1–3 pieces per day depending on your dog's size and activity level. Always read the guaranteed analysis and feeding guidelines on the specific product label.

Can I use Crumps' Naturals treats for dogs with dental disease?

Crumps' Naturals Plaque Busters are designed to reduce tartar build-up through mechanical chewing action and natural ingredients. They can be a useful part of a dental hygiene routine for dogs with mild plaque accumulation. However, if your dog already has diagnosed dental disease, broken teeth, or is recovering from a dental procedure, you should consult your veterinarian before introducing any chew-style treat. Dogs with advanced dental disease may need softer treat formats — in which case Crumps' Naturals freeze-dried bites or Fare Game soft air-dried pieces are gentler options. For broader dental product options, explore dog health and wellness products at Ashario Pets.

Where can I buy Kettle Craft, Crumps' Naturals, and Fare Game dog treats in Toronto or North York?

All three brands are available at Ashario Pets, located at 1111A Finch Ave W, Unit 2, North York, ON M3J 2P7. The store is open 7 AM to 11 PM daily, 365 days a year — including holidays. You can also order online for same-day delivery in the GTA through Uber Eats, DoorDash, SkipTheDishes, Instacart, and Fantuan. For questions about specific SKUs or stock availability, call +1-647-564-4433 or visit the Ashario Pets contact page. Browse the top pet product brands in Canada page for a full overview of what we carry.